This was a closely-fought contest! The judge, Brian Laws, judged an interesting way using three parts -

a) How good is the original picture?

b) How good is the conversion to make it look like a painting?

c) What is the resultant overall effect?

 

Using this model, he was lavish in his praise for some of the pictures and critical of those which showed little resemblance to a painting.

The overall result was:

Set subject - like a painting PDIs Mono Colour Total
Chris Goody 37 37 35 109
Marc Brimble 34 39 33 106
Dave Munn 34 33 36 103
Martyn Daniel 38 33 31 102
John Edge 37 32 33 102
Paul Hayward 35 30 37 102
Sandy Robertson 31 31 32 94
Patrick Miles 32 30 31 93
Stuart Ord 30 28 35 93
Peter Starkey 27 32 30 89
Peter Brown 26 31 29 86
David Powell 27   29 56
Allan Heath 27   27 54
Ruth Elner 30     30
Fred Cooper     13 13

 

The individual rounds were as follows.

Colour prints:

Title Author Score Place
Nude chair & bed Paul Hayward 20 1
Swans taking off from the snow and ice Chris Goody 19 2
Who's calling Harry Dave Munn 19 2
Enchanted forest John Edge 18 3
Fuschia Stuart Ord 18 3
Beach riders Dave Munn 17  
Burano ripples Marc Brimble 17  
Hands on Paul Hayward 17  
Old petrol pumps Sandy Robertson 17  
Forest mushrooms Stuart Ord 17  
Forest in a blizzard Chris Goody 16  
Painting in light Marc Brimble 16  
Lake Geneva Martyn Daniel 16  
Indian temple Patrick Miles 16  
Across the sandbank David Powell 15  
Loch Garry John Edge 15  
Kite Surfing Martyn Daniel 15  
Aira Force Patrick Miles 15  
Water colour rose Peter Brown 15  
Full steam ahead Peter Starkey 15  
Roof tops Peter Starkey 15  
Amaryllis Sandy Robertson 15  
Firey dawn from Jubilee Park Allan Heath 14  
Reflecting David Powell 14  
River at Tywyn Peter Brown 14  
Eillean Nan Ron - forgotten isle Allan Heath 13  
Dinas Dinlle Fred 13  

Mono prints:

Title Author Score Place
A glacier descending from Baffin Island Chris Goody 20 1
Glass and tumbler still life Marc Brimble 20 1
Chiaroscuro - Light and shade Marc Brimble 19 2
Bengal tiger Dave Munn 18 3
Flight of swans Chris Goody 17  
The Hit Maker Martyn Daniel 17  
Winter snow Peter Brown 17  
The windmill Peter Starkey 17  
Misty morning ride John Edge 16  
Abstract mask John Edge 16  
Nile Rodgers Martyn Daniel 16  
Moreton Corbett Patrick Miles 16  
Photographers singing a tribute to Dali Sandy Robertson 16  
Street beggar and his dogs Dave Munn 15  
Silver lady on baxyfull buddha Paul Hayward 15  
Lady in light box Paul Hayward 15  
The stables Peter Starkey 15  
Medieval man pen and ink Sandy Robertson 15  
Wing walker Stuart Ord 15  
Charcoal kiln Patrick Miles 14  
Cormorants Peter Brown 14  
Performance Stuart Ord 13  

PDIs:

Title Author Score Place
A pair of red-crowned cranes Chris Goody 20 Joint 1st
Warhol of the North Martyn Daniel 20 Joint 1st
Isle of Harris abstract Marc Brimble 19 3rd
Dancing Vettriano style Paul Hayward 19  
Orange rose John Edge 19  
Friends Dave Munn 18  
Llanddwyn John Edge 18  
Nile Rodgers in the style of Lichtenstein Martyn Daniel 18  
Birch grove Chris Goody 17  
St Oswalds in Malpas Patrick Miles 17  
The Fall Ruth Elner 17  
Cromer pier line art Sandy Robertson 17  
Harmonica player Stuart Ord 16  
Gyr Saker hybrid falcon "Finished eating" Dave Munn 16  
The butler Paul Hayward 16  
The Grand Canal Marc Brimble 15  
Three ladies in India Patrick Miles 15  
Blue studded wings open Gouache look Sandy Robertson 14  
Running out of steam Allan Heath 14  
St Benets abbey David Powell 14  
Tudor House Peter Starkey 14  
Steam punk Stuart Ord 14  
Remains in isolation Allan Heath 13  
In memoriam paint David Powell 13  
A wet day in Shrewsbury Peter Brown 13  
Beached Peter Starkey 13  
Sunday at Giverney Ruth Elner 13  
Autumn at Attingham Peter Brown 13  

 

 

 

 

 

 

© Whitchurch Photographic Society 1962 - 2023
Powered by User Agreement